Week 2 Results: M&S overtakes John Lewis as the public's favourite Christmas ad
Awareness of Christmas advertising continues to build momentum, with levels increasing as more advertisers enter the market. The launch of major campaigns from M&S, Waitrose and Morrisons significantly expanded the competitive set, with M&S emerging as the early frontrunner on campaign effectiveness.
What are the key headlines?
- M&S has now overtaken John Lewis as the most-mentioned favourite campaign overall, while Aldi, Sainsbury's, and Tesco remain firmly in contention
- 52% of people are already excited about Christmas, up from 49% last week
- Consumers continue to reward campaigns that balance distinctive festive storytelling with strong brand cues and clear retail relevance.
For the second wave, we put 18 of the season’s earliest Christmas ads to the test to see which campaigns are resonating most with the British public, and here's what we discovered...

M&S has emerged as the early frontrunner on campaign effectiveness
Despite only entering tracking in Week 2, "Home of Christmas" delivers the strongest scores across multiple measures, including empathy (57%), brand feel-good (61%), persuasion (54% food / 52% gifting), and appetite appeal (69%).
Waitrose also makes a strong entry into the race
"Perfect Gift 2" launches with standout food appeal (64%) alongside strong empathy (50%) and positive brand feelings (50%), immediately positioning itself among the strongest-performing food retailers.
John Lewis remains the fame leader
"Don't Give Up on Giving" achieves the highest ad recognition (39%) and it has the second highest branded recognition (26%) behind Aldi (27%), though it has dropped in mentions as people’s favourite Christmas ad.
Morrisons has come in hot in its first week
Morrisons achieved 39% recognition showing how the Bears and Goldie are gaining attention. Brand link may come later as the campaign beds in more - currently 17% recognised the ad and knew it was for Morrisons.
Aldi and Sainsbury’s continue to excel at branded attention
Continued use of Kevin the Carrot and the BFG appear to be helping consumers connect the creative back to the brand ownership for Aldi (27%) and Sainsbury’s (24%), while John Lewis’ legacy and salience focus is helping to keep the brand top of mind.
Amazon and Tesco are gaining familiarity
As the race goes on, branded recognition for Amazon and Tesco grows significantly as more people see them and become familiar with the brand cues/story.

