Sharing Experiences

Stories people can connect with are five times more important than emotions

Sharing Experiences

Stories people can connect with are five times more important than emotions

While emotions make a relative contribution to changing behaviour, we should recognise that a relatable story, one that resonates with the audience because the characters, themes, or situations feel familiar and represent shared experiences, is five times more important.

Stories people can connect to are x5 more important than evoking emotion

% relative contribution to being aTop Third Performer on Behaviour Change

Source: n=15,000 video ads evaluated in Creative|Spark. Each ad was classified by a Generative AI model for having the intent of using creative tactics laddering into the « Brand Value / Narrative » group. Ads in this group were compared to the total database in terms of their likelihood to be Top Third performers.

This significantly greater role of relatable stories speaks to the broader role of empathy in MISFITS experiences.

In MISFITS, we observed that an empathetic experience is critical to behaviour change effects6 and now in relatable stories we can tactically appreciate why this is more important than emotion alone.

It is well established that emotions can support advertising effects and in a previous Ipsos analysis we have observed that they play a strong role in opening the gateways to encode memories. When we analyse second by second ‘Happy’ responses in facial coding when people experience an ad, we indeed observe that top performers on memorability are more likely to evoke this response.7

But when it comes to behaviour, we do not observe the same relationship. This is largely because there is a difference between what can be a fleeting emotion and a story with characters we can more deeply connect with. And it’s in this evidence for the power of narrative and characters more broadly that we see a need to do more than evoke a smile. Instead, we need to express empathy for our audience through stories they can connect with.

Empathy and fitting in

A feeling that the ad has been created with the audience in mind. WIth a focus on their needs, challenges and lives, and showing how the brand fits within that.

Average happy emotional response by retained branded recognition performance

N=102, per quintile

Further supporting the effectiveness case for relatable stories and characters, many of the most effective ads in the Ipsos database use these tactics as a vehicle to achieve impressive behaviour change effects. Belvedere Vodka featuring the actor Daniel Craig is one such example. It’s on the one hand irreverent, simple fun, watching Craig dance his way through the ad, aided by a glass of Belvedere. Yet on the other, it’s more than this. It’s a progression of events, where art imitates life, where we see Craig enter his chauffeur-driven car in one guise of suave sophistication and emerge from the other side with a carefree dance of a man freed from this stereotype, unshackled from the constraints of his association with his portrayal of James Bond. This sequence of events and transformation from sophistication to fun leads to strong behaviour change effects, in large part because the audience can connect with the character on screen and relate to the fun and carefree experience that Belvedere Vodka can deliver.

Source: Belvedere


BEHAVIOUR CHANGE INDEX

Using a sequence of events depicting a transformation or implications for characters is not the preserve of Hollywood-sized productions. Representing the overall multiplier effect of narratives and the connection they evoke, we consistently see the effectiveness of this approach, from brands big and small.

OVO, a British energy provider, representing a typically lifeless and invisible category, shows a series of people struggle with and talk about the Great British weather. Talking about the weather is a past time as central to British culture as a cup of tea. It’s too wet, too windy, too hot, yet it helps power green energy and the lives of the people that braved the weather conditions.

Source: OVO


BEHAVIOUR CHANGE INDEX

Contact Us and Let's Talk Misfits

Footnotes

6. MISFITS: How creativity in advertising sparks brand growth www.ipsos.com/en/misfits

7. Ipsos Last Impressions Also Count www.ipsos.com/sites/default/files/ct/publication/documents/2018-09/the_impressions_also_count.pdf

MISFITS STORIES

Ipsos

Contact us

Privacy

Cookie Policy